20 March 2012

Tiree: £90K wasted on Art or "We could have had a swimming pool"

On Tiree there is this by the ferry terminal:

Modern Art at the Tiree Ferry Terminal

It is an art installation - and it is not aging gracefully.


"Can you guess how much it cost?" asked one of the islanders
"100K?",
"Close, it was ninety thousand pounds - we could have had something for the kiddies but no we had to have this art thing"

It is all getting a bit decayed and manky inside
But most of all it blocks a view like this...

  
...with this

The owner of the cottage spent her last three years, on oxygen, dieing from emphysema, sitting in her front room staring at two slabs of concrete instead of Traigh Mohr:


Prints of this image are for sale at http://www.hebrideanmagic.com/traigh_mhor_tiree.htm


From the web:
 "An Turus is an award winning arts project, based at the ferry port. The building won the prestigious “Scottish Building of the Year” award in 2003."



"and was designed, as a place to shelter from the elements whilst waiting on the local ferry arriving."

There is a perfectly good heated waiting room at the ferry port - and a shop that does hot snacks. 


Here is a review (warning you will need a sick bag) I suppose the problem is that architects, like lawyers, are very-clever-people and money is always going to flow their way.



There is a whole, high cost, industry set up around such works of art - some works work (Mr Gormley for example) but most do not.


6 comments:

Jenny said...

How inconsiderate of Brian Milne to die and let An Turas fall into disrepair. Perhaps if some of the people who moan about the state of An Turas would volunteer to help repair and maintain it, it would be a nicer sight for visitors to the island such as yourself.

The thing about this blog post is, it's a good five years out of date. Tiree has a wind turbine which generates money for the island, goes towards community projects, including “something for the kiddies”.

P.S You spelt dying wrong.

David Williams said...

Just becos I can't spel does not mean I am rong - cheap shot Jenny

I was not moaning about the state of it - just the it-of-it.

It was an eyesore, it still is an eyesore, it will remain an eyesore until bulldozed

J MacIntosh said...

I am a permanent Tiree resident. When An Turas was built there were many differing views expressed regarding its appearance, cost etc. Regardless of your view, An Turas is now a feature of the island, and for many of us who live here, it is a reminder of a highly respected member of our community who contributed hugely to the island over many years. We all have just one shot at life in this world; wouldn't it be better to make a positive contribution, rather than saying things which only hurt and upset people?

David Williams said...

No intention to hurt or upset.

Surprised that my subjective observations have had this effect.

Probably best to close this matter now.

Anonymous said...

This is a fantastic, simple combination of art and architecture. Im studying this structure as part of my masters disseration and frankly it makes a whole lot more sense than a swimming pool ever would.

Also I think its pretty narrow minded of you to think that "architects like lawyers will always have money flowing to them", you clearly dont understand the struggles of architects, so a bit of advice...i would'nt make comments like that in the future, it makes you come across naive.

I understand you concerns, even though i think your only looking at this from one point of view, which makes me think that you are just one of those busy body, neighbourhood watch people who dont liek change, therefore attack new developments aimed to improve facilities such as this. Thats all i have to say.
Kind regards

David Williams said...

Wow - what a hornet's nest I have stirred up. I am a narrow minded, naive busybody - excellent. I don't normally publish anonymous comments but for the above I make an exception.

I still stand by what I said. Go and see it yourself and make your own mind up.

It is impressive just how strongly folks feel about this construction - perhaps that was the point?